The text from Rhoda came while our church bus was pulling into Marathon. “You made it to the Keys?” That was all. I hadn’t told her I was coming, at least not directly, and I remember reading it twice while the other ladies were getting their purses out. I typed, “I’m here for lunch,” then erased it. I didn’t know why I wanted to answer carefully.
I was seventy-one, retired from nursing, and I’d been a widow for two years. At least, that was what I’d told the church ladies when they asked. Lamar had drowned in Lake Seminole, though nobody ever found his body. The sheriff said his boat was drifting without him. His cap and thermos were inside. His life jacket was under the seat, where it usually was.
They searched for nine days. I remember the number because I kept counting the days on the calendar in the kitchen, then stopping myself because counting didn’t help. Divers came. Dogs came. Half the county took boats out. On the last day, one of the men told me the drowned timber under the lake held on to things. He meant to be kind. I knew that. Still, I wanted to ask him what he knew about timber.
We had a service at First Baptist with an empty casket. I sat in the front row and listened to people talk about Lamar as if I’d never met him.
I’d worked as a nurse for forty-one years. I’d seen people die. I’d closed eyes and called families. I hadn’t known how strange it would feel to bury a box with no body in it.
For most of our forty-seven years, Lamar whistled two notes when he came back to the dock. High, then low. He used to say the old bird dog could hear it from anywhere. When the dog died, Lamar kept doing it, mostly because I’d start supper when I heard him. I didn’t realize how much I’d built my evenings around those two notes until I stopped hearing them.
A few months after the funeral, I still set out two coffee cups some mornings. Not every morning. I’m not claiming that. I’d reach for the second cup, then put it back in the cupboard. It became a habit I could hide from myself if I moved fast enough. Anyway, there were other things to deal with.
The bank called about the bait shop. Lamar had run it for years, and Rhoda had kept the books there for eleven of them. I’d known Rhoda for thirty years. She was at my kitchen table when I signed the papers Lamar put in front of me. He said the signature was for boat insurance. I didn’t read every line. I wish I could say I had, but I didn’t.
Two months after the funeral, the bank told me I owed $90,000 on a note tied to the shop. My name was on it. I sold the shop, then the truck, then what was left of our savings. The bank officer said the account had less in it than I expected. I said the shop must have eaten through it. That sounded simple enough at the time.
The insurance company wouldn’t pay without a body. They said the claim could stay open, but it might be years before they could do anything.
I asked what I was supposed to live on while I waited. The woman on the phone said she was sorry, and I told her I knew she didn’t make the rules. That was true. I was also angry at her, which wasn’t fair.
I went back through my old nursing paperwork because I needed to know what was coming in and what was going out. The numbers didn’t add up. I found receipts for fuel, boat parts, and shop supplies, but nothing that explained the money missing from the savings account. I didn’t call the bank back. I was tired of asking people questions when they could answer with a form letter.
I sold the shop to a couple from Bainbridge. I watched them carry boxes out through the front door and felt like I’d helped take Lamar away for a second time. I also felt relieved to be done with the debt. Both feelings can sit in the same chair, I guess.
Rhoda stayed with me through the funeral. She brought food, answered the door when I couldn’t, and kept rubbing the same spot on my hand while people came in and out. I remember her saying, “You don’t have to do anything today.” I believed she was helping me. I still believe she meant to help me, at least then.
Four months later, she moved to the Florida Keys. She told me the warm air might help her arthritis. Her husband, Clifton, had died in 2019, so I figured she wanted a change. She sent two postcards. One had pelicans. The other showed a crab shack with blue umbrellas. She wrote that she was getting used to the heat and missing the people back home.
The calls got shorter after that. I’d ask how she was, and she’d say fine. Then she’d say she had to run. I told myself grief made people act odd. I know grief. I know people don’t always want to talk. I didn’t want to be one more person asking Rhoda to take care of me when she was trying to start over.
Still, there were little things. She stopped asking how the debt was going. When I told her I’d sold the shop, she changed the subject to her arthritis. I thought she might be ashamed that she’d kept the books and hadn’t caught whatever Lamar did. I didn’t want to make her feel worse. I’ve spent a good part of my life trying not to make other people feel worse.
I kept Lamar’s cell number taped beside the landline. It was written in his blocky handwriting, the number he’d had for years. I didn’t use it. I wasn’t even sure the phone was still on. I kept it there because taking it down felt like saying something I wasn’t ready to say. That’s all.
Ione from Sunday school signed me up for the church trip to Key West. I told her I couldn’t afford a vacation. She knew about the coffee can I kept over the stove, which I didn’t know she knew about. She said, “Pay me back when you can.” I said that wasn’t charity if I paid her back. She said, “Then we agree.” I went.
We rode for nine hours with forty church ladies, pimento cheese sandwiches, and a cooler that kept sliding into the aisle. I sat near the front because my knees bother me if I’m cramped. I didn’t talk much. The trip felt like a thing I could do without explaining why I was doing it.
When we got to Marathon, I asked the driver if we could stop for lunch. I had Rhoda’s postcard in my purse. I’d looked up the crab shack before we left, though I told myself it was only because I liked the place in the picture. I wanted to see where she lived. I wanted to surprise her. I also wanted proof that she was doing all right, which sounds silly now.
That’s when I read her text again. “You made it to the Keys?” I didn’t answer. The bus had stopped, and I could hear the ladies getting excited about the water and the menus. I put my phone away and followed the group down the dock.
The crab shack had tables outside beneath blue umbrellas. I’d seen them on Rhoda’s postcard. I went looking for the ladies’ room and heard a man whistle from one of the tables. Two notes. High, then low.
I stopped walking. Not because I didn’t know the sound. I knew it too well. I’d heard it from the dock for forty-seven years, and I’d spent two years telling myself I’d never hear it again.
The man was sitting with his back partly turned. He had a white beard. Lamar had grown one the fall he died, or the fall I thought he died. He’d told me it was for deer season. I knew the shape of his ears. I knew the way he held his coffee cup with his thumb on the handle. I knew his shoulders.
Rhoda sat across from him in a straw hat. He leaned over and kissed her. Not a quick greeting. It was the same kind of kiss he used to give me by the stove when he came in from the dock.
I took out my phone and took a picture. My hand was steady. I took another because I didn’t trust my eyes, though the second picture showed the same thing. Ione came up beside me and followed my gaze. She put a hand on my arm. I didn’t look at her.
I had paid the note. I’d sold the shop. I’d sat at an empty casket while Rhoda held my hand. Those things went through my mind one at a time, like a nurse checking a chart before a procedure. The picture on my phone stayed bright and small in my palm.
Ione whispered, “Roberta, is that Lamar?” I said, “Yes.” She held on to my arm, and I felt how hard she was gripping it. She told me the bus was waiting and that I didn’t have to walk over there. She said I could take the picture home and call the sheriff.
I looked at Rhoda. She laughed at something Lamar said. It was the same laugh she’d used at my kitchen table for thirty years. I could have gone back to the bus. I could have called somebody who knew the law. I could have waited until my hands stopped shaking. I walked to the table instead.
Lamar looked up. The color left his face, and for one second I almost reached out to check his pulse. That is the stupidest part, but it’s true. Rhoda’s fork slipped from her hand and hit the boards under the table.
She said my name. Lamar pushed his chair back. Ione stayed a few steps behind me. A waitress came over with a pad in her hand, smiled at him, and asked if he wanted anything else, Mister, She glanced at the table, then at the name printed on the card beside his plate. “Mr. Ashby, do you need anything else?”
I took another picture. I didn’t ask him why he was alive. I already knew the answer was going to take more than one sentence, and the church bus was right there, full of people who’d watched me bury him.
I asked Rhoda to come outside with me. She looked at Lamar first. That small glance told me more than anything she said after. He got up and reached for her arm, but Ione stepped between them. Nobody raised their voice. The waitress went back inside with the pad.
Lamar said he could explain. He said he’d been afraid, and that the shop was in trouble, and that he thought the debt would swallow us both. I asked him why he let me bury him. He said he didn’t know how to come back after the first week, then the first month, then the first year. He said it like the time had happened to him, not something he’d chosen.
Rhoda told me she’d learned he was alive before the funeral. She said he called her from Florida and begged her not to tell me until he could get things straight. She said she thought she was helping him get away from the debt, and then she thought she was helping me by keeping the truth from me. I asked her when she decided to stop being my friend. She didn’t answer.
I left them there. I didn’t throw anything. I didn’t slap anyone. I walked back to the bus with my phone in my hand, and Ione stayed close enough to catch me if I needed it. On the ride back, the ladies sang. I watched the road.
The next morning, I took the pictures to the sheriff’s office. I brought the bank papers too. It took time. There were statements, calls, and a meeting with an investigator who asked me to repeat things I’d already said. I did. I gave him the note with my signature and the old account records I had kept in a folder.
Lamar came back to Georgia with a lawyer. Rhoda came back separately. The sheriff’s office opened a fraud case, and the insurance company reopened its file. The money wasn’t going to come back just because I’d found him. The shop was gone. The truck was gone. But I was no longer the only person holding the papers.
I changed the locks on the house. I took Lamar’s number off the wall, then put it in the kitchen drawer instead of throwing it away. I don’t know what I thought I was saving. I told myself it was evidence. Maybe that was all.
Rhoda sent a letter. I read it once, then put it with the bank records. She said she was sorry. She said she knew sorry didn’t fix anything. I believe her. I also know she sat across from him and kissed him while I was still paying the debt he left in my name.
The case is still moving through the county. I’m not going to pretend I know how it will end. I can say what happened: Lamar lived, Rhoda knew, and I was left to bury an empty casket and pay the note. The people who needed to know now know.
The landline is still in the kitchen. I took the tape off the wall, but the pale rectangle where it sat is still there. Some mornings, my hand goes to that spot before I catch myself. I haven’t put the number back.